Here is a simple exploration of the two functions. I found it illuminating going through this exercise. I often will create a simple program exploring the ins and outs of simple functions and save them for reference:
#
# Testing isinstance and issubclass
#
class C1(object):
def __init__(self):
object.__init__(self)
class B1(object):
def __init__(self):
object.__init__(self)
class B2(B1):
def __init__(self):
B1.__init__(self)
class CB1(C1,B1):
def __init__(self):
# not sure about this for multiple inheritance
C1.__init__(self)
B1.__init__(self)
c1 = C1()
b1 = B1()
cb1 = CB1()
def checkInstanceType(c, t):
if isinstance(c, t):
print c, "is of type", t
else:
print c, "is NOT of type", t
def checkSubclassType(c, t):
if issubclass(c, t):
print c, "is a subclass of type", t
else:
print c, "is NOT a subclass of type", t
print "comparing isinstance and issubclass"
print ""
# checking isinstance
print "checking isinstance"
# can check instance against type
checkInstanceType(c1, C1)
checkInstanceType(c1, B1)
checkInstanceType(c1, object)
# can check type against type
checkInstanceType(C1, object)
checkInstanceType(B1, object)
# cannot check instance against instance
try:
checkInstanceType(c1, b1)
except Exception, e:
print "failed to check instance against instance", e
print ""
# checking issubclass
print "checking issubclass"
# cannot check instance against type
try:
checkSubclassType(c1, C1)
except Exception, e:
print "failed to check instance against type", e
# can check type against type
checkSubclassType(C1, C1)
checkSubclassType(B1, C1)
checkSubclassType(CB1, C1)
checkSubclassType(CB1, B1)
# cannot check type against instance
try:
checkSubclassType(C1, c1)
except Exception, e:
print "failed to check type against instance", e
Edit:
Also consider the following as isinstance can break API implementations. An example would be an object that acts like a dictionary, but is not derived from dict. isinstance might check that an object is a dictionary, even though the object supports dictionary style access:
isinstance considered harmful
Edit2:
Can someone please give me an example of a distinction between passing a Type as a second argument versus passing an Object?
After testing the above code it tells me the second parameter must be a type. So in the following case:
checkInstanceType(c1, b1)
The call will fail. It could be written:
checkInstanceType(c1, type(b1))
So if you want to check the type of one instance against another instance you have to use the type() builtin call.
No comments:
Post a Comment